Artistic Limitations in vision – how some artists painted – New York Times
Came across the New York Times article tonight on Simulations of Ailing Artists’ Eyes Yield New Insights on Style which showed what I’ve often suspected, that artists such as Monet, in his later years, were greatly hampered by physical limitation (he could not see very well) and the problems he had reflect in the colors he chose for his later paintings.
“…What has long been known about Monet’s later years is that he suffered from cataracts and that his eyesight worsened so much that he painted from memory. He acknowledged to an interviewer that he was “trusting solely to the labels on the tubes of paint and to the force of habit.â€
Now, thanks to modern digital techniques, scientists and critics can have a better idea how cataracts changed what Monet saw. This year, an ophthalmologist at Stanford, Michael F. Marmor, described in The Archives of Ophthalmology creating computer simulations of Monet’s world as his lenses yellowed, blurring vision and turning patterns of color and light into muddy, unfocused, yellow-green inkblots.”
However, in Art and ageing – an observation, from Art & Perception blog:
“..
Degas suffered macular degeneration, Renoir had rheumatoid arthritis, Mary Cassatt had cataracts and seizures attended to van Gogh. In almost all of these cases, the infirmities that attacked these famous artists happened after their places were assured in history as great artists.Â
This has led me to speculate that once an artist gains recognition, it does not really matter what that artist develops, we just look for and want confirmation of the fact that it was indeed painted by the person – be it illegible scrawls, colors incoherently massing into one other to form a dirty mess or just plain lack of attention to details (details that were earlier captured to meticulous effect) – it does not matter. We overlook incompetence (brought on by the onset of disease, drug overdose or otherwise) and reward the artist for what s(he) were once famous for…”
Tired, time for bed; have yet another post to do but it’ll have to wait till Thursday evening.




